Court denies attempt to shut windowless window seat claims

Meyer v. Delta Air Lines, Inc. (E.D.N.Y. Nov. 4, 2026).  The plaintiffs alleged that the “window seats” they selected on Delta flights sat next to a blank wall.  Two paid extra to select window seats; the third chose hers as a benefit of a Delta-affiliated credit card.  They sued for breach of contract and breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing and alleged promissory estoppel in the alternative.  Delta moved to dismiss, arguing that the Airline Deregulation Act preempted all three claims.  Delta also relied on Rule 2 of its Conditions of Carriage, which states that “seat assignments” and similar details “are not guaranteed and form no part of this contract,” and Rule 24, a merger clause.

The court denied the motion.  It ruled that all three claims fell within the exception recognized in American Airlines, Inc. v. Wolens for claims seeking recovery for an airline’s breach of its own, self-imposed undertakings.  The court reasoned that, because Georgia law lets parties disclaim the implied covenant, the covenant claim arose from an alleged “self-imposed undertaking” and was not preempted under Northwest, Inc. v. Ginsberg.  The promissory estoppel claim also escaped preemption, the court said, because it sought to enforce Delta’s own alleged promise of a window, not a state regulatory policy.

Nor did the Conditions of Carriage require dismissal, per the court.  Delta read Rule 2 as disclaiming any seat guarantee; the plaintiffs read it as letting Delta change seat assignments only when operational changes occur.  The court ruled that the ambiguity could not be resolved on the pleadings.  As to Rule 24, the court held that Delta had not shown that the merger clause defeated the implied covenant and promissory estoppel claims, and two earlier Georgia federal decisions finding that Rule 24 disclaims the covenant lacked “robust analysis.”  The court also ruled that Georgia law allows promissory estoppel to be pleaded in the alternative and that the claim could proceed because it had not yet decided whether the Conditions of Carriage cover the promises alleged.


Leave a Reply