Ninth Circuit again rejects passengers’ deep vein thrombosis arguments

Twardowski v. American Airlines, Inc. (9th Cir. (Cal.) July 30, 2008).  The passengers in these consolidated appeals alleged that they had suffered injuries from deep vein thrombosis (“DVT”) they had developed during flights for which they had bought tickets between 2001 and 2004.  They alleged that the airlines were liable for such injuries because the … More Ninth Circuit again rejects passengers’ deep vein thrombosis arguments

Court declines to dismiss complaint in passenger heart attack case

Watts v. American Airlines, Inc. (S.D. Ind. Oct. 10, 2007).  During a flight from Japan to Chicago in 2005, the passenger had a heart attack and died in a lavatory.  He was discovered by cleaning personnel after the aircraft had landed. The plaintiff, the passenger’s wife, filed a lawsuit against American.  The airline moved to … More Court declines to dismiss complaint in passenger heart attack case

Montreal Convention inapplicable where injured passenger unable to prove that airline regarded multi-airline carriage as “single operation”

Kruger v. United Air Lines, Inc. (N.D. Cal. Nov. 1, 2007).  While waiting on a jetway to board a flight from San Francisco to Seattle, the passenger was inadvertently struck on the head by a backpack swung by another boarding passenger.  The passenger was able to board but became “dazed and nauseated” during the flight … More Montreal Convention inapplicable where injured passenger unable to prove that airline regarded multi-airline carriage as “single operation”

Passenger’s seating decision dooms her personal injury lawsuit

Zarlin v. Air France (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 6, 2007).  A flight attendant reseated the passenger during an international flight after she complained that the passenger in front of her had deliberately reclined his seat so that it touched her.  Without informing a flight attendant, the passenger returned to her original seat because the alternative seat was … More Passenger’s seating decision dooms her personal injury lawsuit

Court analyzes “accident” location in ruling on passenger remand motion

Bunis v. Israir GSA, Inc. and Israir Airlines & Tourism, Ltd. (E.D.N.Y. July 30, 2007).  The passenger arrived at JFK on an international flight and deplaned.  At the arrival gate, the passenger asked an airline employee for a wheelchair.  After waiting 20 minutes, the passenger started walking toward the baggage claim area.  In the international … More Court analyzes “accident” location in ruling on passenger remand motion

Injured passenger prevails on issue of whether “accident” occurred

Wipranik v. Air Canada (C.D. Cal. May 15, 2007).  During a flight from Canada to Israel in 2004, the passenger asked a flight attendant for a cup of hot tea.  After the passenger had placed the cup on her tray table, the seat in front of her moved, causing the cup to slide off the … More Injured passenger prevails on issue of whether “accident” occurred

Court grants summary judgment against “undeserving litigant” in personal injury lawsuit

Agravante v. Japan Airlines International Co., Ltd. (D. Guam July 9, 2007).  The passenger claimed in his lawsuit against JAL that he suffered back injuries as a result of a “standing takeoff” in 2002.  In a standing takeoff, the flight crew taxis the aircraft to the runway, sets the brakes, sets the engines to a … More Court grants summary judgment against “undeserving litigant” in personal injury lawsuit

Airline not liable for failure to warn in DVT case

James v. Delta Air Lines, Inc. (9th Cir. (Cal.) Jan. 22, 2007).  The Ninth Circuit held that the airline’s failure to warn the passenger of the risk of developing deep vein thrombosis was not an “accident” under Article 17 of the Warsaw Convention.  As a result, the court affirmed the district court’s summary judgment for … More Airline not liable for failure to warn in DVT case

Airlines not liable for passengers’ DVT

Cortez v. Air New Zealand Ltd. (9th Cir. (Cal.) Oct. 2, 2006) & Damon v. Air Pacific Ltd. (9th Cir. (Cal.) Oct. 2, 2006).  In virtually identical opinions, the Ninth Circuit held that neither the passengers’ development of deep vein thrombosis (“DVT”) nor the airlines’ failure to warn the passengers of the risk of DVT constitutes an “accident” as that term … More Airlines not liable for passengers’ DVT

Airline not liable for downgrading passenger tickets

Sobol v. Continental Airlines (S.D.N.Y. Sept. 26, 2006).  Due to overbookings, the airline downgraded some of the first class tickets held by family members to coach class, causing the family to be separated during the international flights at issue. The family members alleged in their lawsuit that the separation caused them emotional trauma and stress, but no physical injury.  … More Airline not liable for downgrading passenger tickets